ThredUP vs. Poshmark - Which One is a Better E-Commerce Platform

Ryan Barnett · September 19, 2024

 

If you want to create a clothing empire, you know how hard it can be to find the perfect e-commerce platform with all the features. A resale platform that offers you convenient declutters of your wardrobe and engages customers in a sustainable environment can help you start a business. To help you choose the best platform, this article will provide ThredUP vs. Poshmark by looking at their different aspects.

Table of Contents

  1. 01 A Basic Understanding of the ThredUP Platform
  2. 02 A Quick Overview of Poshmark
  3. 03 ThredUP vs Poshmark - Sign Up
  4. 04 ThredUP vs. Poshmark - Categories & Audience Reach
  5. 05 ThredUP vs Poshmark - Profit & Commission
  6. 06 ThredUP vs Poshmark - Payout Options
  7. 07 ThredUP vs Poshmark - Comparison Analysis
  8. 08 Useful Tips to Upscale Your Sales Using Other Tools for ThredUP and Poshmark

Part 1. A Basic Understanding of the ThredUP Platform

When hunting for a customizable thrift shop with an expanded array of secondhand clothing brands, we have found the perfect match for you. ThredUP is an online thrift store where you can curate and process a vast collection of clothing, shoes, and other items on sale. This platform delivers a modern resale experience for all women's and children's apparel with over 55K brands and up to 90% off.

While comparing ThredUP vs. Poshmark, ThredUP's proprietary technology can find over 100K unique items for everyday use. This platform also provides users with a style chat feature where they can describe their style with a prompt to receive accurate clothing options. You can take a peek at their collaborators and look at the celebrity closet to get a piece.

Part 2. A Quick Overview of Poshmark

You can enjoy a community of millions of members where you can find a unique set of clothing brands in different styles and hard-to-find pieces. In the Poshmark vs. ThredUP comparison, Poshmark lets you buy, sell, and discover quality secondhand clothes, accessories, and more. It offers a whole wardrobe of different items in various sizes, styles, and trends with up to 70% off.

Furthermore, you can shop with confidence as Poshmark protects payment, offers authentic items, and more. As a seller, you can sell almost anything on this e-commerce platform, such as home goods, pets, and clothes. With the daily themed Posh Parties, you can attract various shoppers and earn cash after delivery. Furthermore, there is no need to add stamps before delivering the product and drop it in the USPS mailbox.      

Part 3. ThredUP vs Poshmark - Sign Up 

In this section, we'll discover various steps of how you can make an account on both of the previously discussed e-commerce platforms. This will also explain the main difference of comparison in ThredUP vs. Poshmark. Follow the given instructions and learn how you can buy and sell your own brand of clothes, accessories, and more using these platforms:

ThredUP

Instructions. Access the main website of ThredUP, click the "Sign in" button, and create an account using any desired method. Now, click the "Sell" tab, select the "Get a Clean Out Kit" button, and choose to sell the clothes you want. After that, press the "Get My Kit" and once you choose to order a label and bag, the website will provide an estimated processing time and price.     

Introduction of Thredup and how to use - Thredup vs Poshmark 

Poshmark

Instructions. Start by setting up your seller's account by signing in with a Google, Facebook, or Apple account. Moving forward, launch your product by taking photos of it and enhancing the images by changing the background, brightness, filters, and more. Now, you can add a "Title" and "Description" of your product and set up a price range.

Introduction of Poshmark and how to use - Thredup vs Poshmark 

Part 4. ThredUP vs. Poshmark - Categories & Audience Reach 

When we look at the comparison of ThredUP vs. Poshmark for sellers, we see that both platforms work on selling and buying secondhand products. However, they cater to slightly different audiences and offer different categories. Discover what they are by reading the following points as we looked at the audience reach and categories of both platforms:

ThredUP

ThredUP is the largest online selling and buying platform, with over 1.7 million active users in countries such as the United States and Canada. Moreover, this platform offers a wide range of 4.4M unique clothing items for women and children.

Categories 

  • Women
  • Shoes
  • Handbags
  • Accessories
  • Women Clothing
  • Kid's Clothing
  • Maternity 

Poshmark

For people who enjoy shopping and selling simple, social, and sustainable products, Poshmark is an excellent platform. This website has over 100 million users, is actively present in Canada and the US, and caters to a large demographic.

Categories 

  • Women's Clothing
  • Men's Clothing
  • Kids' clothing
  • Home décor
  • Electronics
  • Accessories
  • Pet clothing + accessories
  • Makeup

Part 5. ThredUP vs Poshmark - Profit & Commission

In this section, we will discuss how much the seller gains and what commission these e-commerce stores take. If we look at the ThredUP vs. Poshmark selling techniques, both take different approaches that impact how much sellers ultimately earn:

ThredUP

The dynamic algorithm of ThredUP is designed to maximize the seller's earnings by selling various clothing items at the price of their choice. While selling on this platform, you can increase the prices by 10% and decrease them up to $4.99 as you add items to your cart. With an item selling at $5-$19.99, you'll earn $0.15-$2.99 (3%-15%) while you can gain up to 80% of the selling price with a $200+ tag.

Poshmark

This e-commerce store charges a flat fee of $2.95 for sales of items priced at $15 or below. For items sold over $15, they take a 20% commission from the sale price. This transparency and lower commission make Poshmark potentially more profitable for sellers, for those who prefer a hands-on approach.

Part 6. ThredUP vs Poshmark - Payout Options 

When we talk about the different payment options, ThredUP vs. Poshmark uses different structures and accepts cards and payments. The following are their different payment options, which you can find on their website when buying:

ThredUP

While buying different clothing items from ThredUP, it accepts major credit cards and debit cards. You can use Visa, JCB, and American Express but cannot pay without a registered billing address. Moreover, you can also pay with PayPal and AfterPay.

Poshmark

Poshmark offers various payment methods to its users, such as credit cards, Apple Pay, Venmo, and Affirm. This platform offers much faster access to funds, making it a better option for sellers seeking quick payouts. Furthermore, you can receive money via a direct deposit to your bank account or can request a check.

Part 7. ThredUP vs Poshmark - Comparison Analysis 

Apart from the above-discussed information, we will provide a much digestible and easily understandable comparison table of ThredUP vs. Poshmark. These basic pros and cons of both platforms provide you with a clear picture of which tool is more suitable to your needs:

ThredUP

Pros

  • Focuses on convenience and sustainability
  • Convenient with higher fees
  • Sellers earn up to 80% on item price
  • Handles sellers' wardrobe

Cons

  • Items can take weeks or even months to sell
  • Sellers don't have control over the price
  • Longer and more complex payout process
  • ThredUP charges a fee for item return policy\

ThredUP is Best For: This platform is ideal for individuals who are seeking an organized selling experience. For those who want to sell high-end and designer items in an environment-conscious environment, this turns out as a good option. Moreover, if you are looking to promote sustainable fashion without much effort, then ThredUP is perfect for you.

Poshmark

Pros

  • More hands-on and community-driven
  • Profitable for sellers willing to manage the sales
  • More payment options for your customers
  • Posh Parties create a vibrant community of buyers and sellers

Cons

  • Less availability in other countries
  • High flat shipping fee for buyers
  • Sellers face disputes for a returned item
  • Slow sales 

Poshmark is Best For: People who are fashion enthusiasts and enjoy curating their own listings and engaging, Poshmark is for them. It is perfect for gaining higher profits, controlling pricing and shipping, and more. You can reach a targeted audience using Poshmark's social features and sell trendy or niche products.

Part 8. Useful Tips to Upscale Your Sales Using Other Tools for ThredUP and Poshmark 

We have discussed Poshmark vs. ThredUP, and it's clear that you need a photo editing tool to build an effective and successful store. insMind is an effective AI photo editing online tool that helps you create studio-quality photos. It comes with a whole collection of editing tools that ensure to boost sales and increase productivity rate. The following are some of the advanced tools you can utilize to expand your online store empire:

1. Stretch Images To Improve Outlook

The free AI image extender can seamlessly expand the image contents with extreme precision without stretching. The results look highly professional because of its AI technology, which improves the selling assets of your products.

Use insMind  AI Image Extender to Enhance Images - Thredup vs Poshmark 

2. Change Background Using AI For Enhanced Representation

You can generate new and stunning backgrounds with a click with the AI background to attract the audience's attention. These backgrounds come in various styles and categories, like texture, indoor, and plain. For an impressive and creative product representation, replace the original background and expertly change it with AI ones.

Use insMind's AI Background Changer to enhance e-commerce images - Thredup vs Poshmark 

3. Include Text To Mark Important Details

insMind offers to add text to photo features with thousands of free fonts and styles, making products stand out among the rest. Moreover, this feature provides an extensive gallery of pre-designed text in various categories, like neon and heading, to help you create posters.

Use insMind's tool add text to photo to enhance e-commerce images - Thredup vs Poshmark 

4. Magnify Product Visuals With Improved Designs

If you don't know where to start, then use the AI design generator, as it produces stunning product visuals in seconds. Additionally, you can make flyers, banners, and advertising posters of your product with added benefits in multiple templates.

Ecommerce merchants' helper insMind's AI Design Generator - Thredup vs Poshmark 

5. Add Shadows For a Realistic Effect

The AI Shadows offered by insMind helps include a shadowy effect across a particular picture. With 10+ different shadow effects and 360-degree angle options, you can improve your product's outlook. It also allows you to manage the effect by adjusting its opacity, length, width, and blur effect.

Use insMind's AI Shadows feature to create a realistic style - Thredup vs Poshmark

Conclusion 

To conclude this article, we went through a complete understanding of the two platforms, ThredUP vs. Poshmark. If you want a better cloth selling and buying website, you can try these two websites as we lay out every aspect of them. In the comparison table, we learned that ThredUP is more sustainable and has better earnings. Poshmark is community-driven for self-managing sellers who want better control.

Moreover, you can achieve an impressive, centered product display by using insMind product editing features that can take your sales to the next level. Head over to its website and learn how to create and edit professional, studio-quality product photos for your store.

Ryan Barnett · I'm a freelance writer with a passion for editing and designing photos. Here at insMind, I strive to educate users on image creativity, photography, and enhancing product photos to help grow their businesses.